Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Grails: Intercepting Service class methods - part 3

Well - I have a couple of updates to my previous post:

1) Grails 1.2.2 is out and it does look like the Spring DSL for AOP definitions is fixed.
2) using the Spring xml definition in part 2 performed very poorly. I am not sure why but if I changed the pointcut definition to:

pointcut="execution(* com.redpointtech.flex..*Service..*(..))"


it performed MUCH better

Given that the DSL is fixed and I needed it to perform better I have changed the AOP definition again to the following in the resources.groovy file.

 beans = {  
xmlns aop:"http://www.springframework.org/schema/aop"
securityAspect(SecurityAspect)
aop {
config("proxy-target-class":true) {
aspect(id:'theSecurityAspectDef', ref:'securityAspect') {
around method: "invoke", pointcut:"execution(* com.redpointtech.flex..*Service..*(..))"
}
}
}
}


I think this concludes my saga to get Flex services intercepted. I hope this helps you out.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Grails: Intercepting Service class methods - part 2

As a continuation from my earlier post about intercepting Grails Service methods - as it turns out that approach will not work when using flex-remoting. If you want to intercept your services that you expose as Flex services you have to use Spring AOP. Because of a bug: http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/GRAILS-5932 you will have to use the XML version of AOP definition.

To do that you have to create a resources.xml file in grails-app/conf/spring directory and it would look like the following:

 <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>  
<beans xmlns="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans"
xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
xmlns:aop="http://www.springframework.org/schema/aop"
xsi:schemaLocation="
http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans/spring-beans-3.0.xsd
http://www.springframework.org/schema/aop http://www.springframework.org/schema/aop/spring-aop-3.0.xsd">
<!--
we are defining the AOP beans in the xml file because of this bug which will
not be fixed until 1.2.2 and we are using 1.2.1
http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/GRAILS-5932
aspect are called twice because of the above bug. See
http://n4.nabble.com/Advice-called-2-or-more-times-for-aspect-with-execution-pointcut-Bug-td1588831.html
toward the bottom Graeme says that 1.2.2 will have the fixes, and 1.3 M1 already does have the
fix. For now we have to live with the interceptor called twice.
-->
<bean id="myAroundAspect" class="com.redpointtech.aop.MyAroundAspect" />
<aop:config proxy-target-class="true">
<aop:aspect id="theAspect" ref="myAroundAspect">
<aop:around method="invoke" pointcut="target(com.redpointtech.aop.AOPMarkerInterface)" />
</aop:aspect>
</aop:config>
</beans>


This assumes that you want to intercept any class that implements the AOPMarkerInterface.

The Aspect looks like the following:

 class MyAroundAspect {  
public Object invoke(ProceedingJoinPoint joinPoint) throws Throwable {
Object returnVal = null
println "MyAroundAspect called...."
returnVal = joinPoint.proceed()
return returnVal
}
}


A couple of take aways:
1) do not try to do what I suggested in my previous blog post. That will NOT work for Flex services
2) do not use resources.groovy and the Spring DSL - there is a bug in the 1.2.x version that prevents that from working. This is suppose to be fixed in the 1.2.2 release ( not yet released) and the 1.3 M1 ( available now )
3) do use resources.xml and define your Aspect the old fashion way - the old ways work just great.

I hope this saves you some time.

Saturday, March 13, 2010

Grails: Intercepting Service class methods

It took me a little while to fully understand how to add some kind of interceptor to a Grails Service class and I wanted to add a blog post incase others have a similar question. After doing some research, and piecing together information from various sites I ended up with the information here. I hope it is helpful to you.

What problem am I trying to solve?
Adding interceptors to Controllers is really easy and I wanted to add some interceptors to my Service classes in a similar fashion. But it appears that you cannot do this for Service classes - just Controller classes. If I am wrong, please someone show me how best to do this.

Why am I trying to do this?
I use Flex in many of my application implementations and I use BlazeDS/AMF in many of the cases. I needed to add a security check on every exposed Flex service.

How did I do this?
In my service class I added a custom property that I called 'secureService'. But as you will see you can use anything.

 class TeslaService {  
boolean transactional = true
// secureService is a custom property that is looked for in the BootStrap.groovy file and if
// found in a ServiceClass, then it modifies the invokeMethod to add some code before and
// after the call.
boolean secureService = true
def serviceMethod() {
println 'Tesla Service Method called'
}
}


Next I updated my BootStrap.groovy file and for each ServiceClass, checked for the 'secureService' property being set to true. If it was, I then used the MetaClass InvokeMethod and assigned a new closure that could add a security check.

The updated bootstrap file looked like the following:
 class BootStrap {  
def grailsApplication
def init = { servletContext ->
grailsApplication.serviceClasses.each {
def isSecured = it.getPropertyValue('secureService')
if( isSecured ) {
// example of how to 'intercept' service classes.
it.metaClass.invokeMethod = { name, args ->
println '''SECURE before $name'''
def res = delegate.metaClass.getMetaMethod(name,args).invoke( delegate, args)
println '''SECURE after $name. res=$res'''
res
}
}
}
}
def destroy = {
}
}


To test this I created an Integration test. This test looked like the following:

 class TeslaServiceIntegrationTests extends GrailsUnitTestCase {  
def teslaService
protected void setUp() {
super.setUp()
}
protected void tearDown() {
super.tearDown()
}
void testServiceMethod() {
teslaService.serviceMethod()
}
}


The output of this was the following:
SECURE before serviceMethod
Tesla Service Method called
SECURE after serviceMethod. res=null

Some of the links that I used are below as the information from these posts might also be helpful to you.

http://www.pubbs.net/grails/201001/9868/
http://mrhaki.blogspot.com/2010/01/grails-goodness-access-grails.html
http://www.grails.org/doc/latest/api/org/codehaus/groovy/grails/commons/ClassPropertyFetcher.html

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

FlexBuilder 3 and FlexUnit4 RC1

This will be a quick post on how to setup FlexBuilder project to use FlexUnit4. This post will be more prescriptive with just the steps without a lot of explanation. The FlexUnit site has good documentation.

1) Setup a Flex Project as you normally would.
2) Download the FlexUnit4 from this link.
3) Unzip and copy all of the swc files to your projects libs directory. There should be 4 swc files.
4) create a package/folder under the src directory called flexUnitTests. It could be called anything.
5) Create a test Suite class. This is just a POAO ( plain old actionscript object ). I called mine FlexUnit4Suite and it looked like the following:
1:  package flexUnitTests  
2: {
3: import org.flexunit.runners.Suite;
4: [Suite]
5: [RunWith("org.flexunit.runners.Suite")]
6: public class FlexUnit4Suite
7: {
8: public var testCase1:MyTestCase;
9: }
10: }


Lines 4 and 5 are the most interesting. Use the Suite and RunsWith metadata tags. Line 8 is a reference to your TestCase class. As you add more TestCase classes, just add a new variable here. You dont have to instantiate it, or anything - just declare it.

6) Create your TestCase class, which again is a POAO. Mine looked like the following:

1:  package flexUnitTests  
2: {
3: import flexunit.framework.Assert;
4: public class MyTestCase
5: {
6: public function MyTestCase()
7: {
8: }
9: [BeforeClass]
10: public static function runBeforeClass():void {
11: trace("runBeforeClass");
12: }
13: [AfterClass]
14: public static function runAfterClass():void {
15: trace("runAfterClass");
16: }
17: [Before]
18: public function runBeforeEveryTest():void
19: {
20: trace("runBeforeEveryTest");
21: }
22: [After]
23: public function runAfterEveryTest():void
24: {
25: trace("runAfterEveryTest");
26: }
27: [Test]
28: public function testTrue():void
29: {
30: trace("checkMethod");
31: Assert.assertTrue( true );
32: }
33: [Ignore("Not Ready to Run")]
34: [Test]
35: public function testNotReady():void
36: {
37: Assert.assertFalse( true );
38: }
39: }
40: }


7) Create a new Application for the test runner. You dont have to create a new application, but I assume you already have an Application class that really runs your application. I created another Application called FlexUnitTestRunner. It looked like the following:

1:  <?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>  
2: <mx:Application xmlns:mx="http://www.adobe.com/2006/mxml" layout="absolute"
3: xmlns:flexunitrunning="http://www.adobe.com/2009/flexUnitUIRunner"
4: minWidth="1024" minHeight="768" creationComplete="onCreationComplete()">
5: <mx:Script>
6: <![CDATA[
7: import flexUnitTests.FlexUnit4Suite;
8: import org.flexunit.listeners.UIListener;
9: import org.flexunit.runner.FlexUnitCore;
10: private var flexUnitCore:FlexUnitCore;
11: private function onCreationComplete():void {
12: flexUnitCore = new FlexUnitCore();
13: flexUnitCore.addListener(new UIListener( testRunner));
14: flexUnitCore.run(FlexUnit4Suite);
15: }
16: ]]>
17: </mx:Script>
18: <flexunitrunning:TestRunnerBase id="testRunner" width="100%" height="100%" />
19: </mx:Application>



Run the FlexUnitTestRunner application and my console output looked like:
1:  runBeforeClass  
2: runBeforeEveryTest
3: checkMethod
4: runAfterEveryTest
5: runAfterClass


and a browser window popped up with the results of my test case.

Thats it in a nutshell how to get a Flex Builder 3, sdk 3.5, FlexUnit4 up and running quickly.

Sunday, January 3, 2010

FlexORM

What seems like many years ago now, because it was - I saw a presentation by Christophe Coenraets where he talked about a simple ORM for AIR. You can see the original blog post here.

I have used Hibernate for many years, and now most recently GORM and I am a big fan of ORM tools when used right and in the right measure.

When I started looking at an AIR application I decided to revisit the work done in that original blog posting and I was very pleased to see that work had continued on with the ORM mapping, now called FlexORM. (Which is an interesting name since it only works with AIR ). You can find more information about the FlexORM tool here.

What I am going to do is present some examples of how I used it. I am hoping that my examples will help answer your questions on how to use the tool or inspire you start using it.

In my simple application my domain model is one where a Project can have sub-projects to form a project hierarchy and each project can have many TimeEntry references but a TimeEntry is only allocated to a single Project.

Lets look at the Project domain class first.
package com.redpointtech.domain
{
import mx.collections.ArrayCollection;
import mx.collections.IList;

[Bindable]
[Table( name="PROJECT")]
public class Project
{
// each project can contain a number of child or
// sub projects.
private var _subProjects:IList = new ArrayCollection();
private var _timeEntries:IList = new ArrayCollection();

[Id]
public var id:int;

[Column( name="proj_name")]
public var name:String;

[Column( name="proj_desc")]
public var desc:String;

[Column(name="color")]
public var color:Number;

[ManyToOne(name="parent_id", inverse="true")]
public var parent:Project;

[OneToMany(type="com.redpointtech.domain.Project", fkColumn="parent_id", lazy="false", cascade="save-update", indexed="true")]
public function set subProjects(value:IList):void {
_subProjects = value;
}
public function get subProjects():IList {
return _subProjects;
}
public function addSubProject(value:Project):void {
value.parent = this;
_subProjects.addItem(value);
}

[OneToMany(type="com.redpointtech.domain.TimeEntry", fkColumn="project_id", lazy="true", cascade="all", indexed="true")]
public function set timeEntries(value:IList):void {
_timeEntries = value;
}
public function get timeEntries():IList {
return _timeEntries;
}
public function addTimeEntry(value:TimeEntry):void {
value.project = this;
_timeEntries.addItem(value);
}


public function Project()
{
}

}
}


The primary metadata tags I used user:
[Table( name="tbd")] to define the table name for the domain object.

[Id] to tell the ORM which field is used for an id. As of right now the id value must be of type 'int'.

[Column( name="tbd")] to define the column name for a property. If the name field is not specified then it uses the property name.

[ManyToOne(name="col name", inverse="true/false")] to define the ManyToOne relationship with itself.

[OneToMany(...)] metadata tag is specific on the set/get methods. Also noticed that we added an 'add' method which sets the parent of the Project and adds the Project to the collection of sub projects.

The TimeEntry class looks like the following:
package com.redpointtech.domain
{
import com.redpointtech.util.Constants;

[Bindable]
[Table( name="TIMEENTRY")]
public class TimeEntry
{

[Id]
public var id:int;

[Column( name="full_year")]
public var fullYear:int;

[Column( name="month")]
public var month:int;

[Column( name="day_of_month")]
public var dayOfMonth:int; // Date.date equivalent

[Column( name="start_hour")]
public var startHour:int;

[Column( name="start_min")]
public var startMin:int;

[Column( name="end_hour")]
public var endHour:int;

[Column( name="end_min")]
public var endMin:int;

[Column( name="notes")]
public var notes:String="";

[Column( name="summary")]
public var summary:String="";

[ManyToOne(name="project_id", inverse="true")]
public var project:Project;

public function TimeEntry()
{
}

public function setDate(date:Date):void {
fullYear = date.fullYear;
month = date.month;
dayOfMonth = date.date;

}
public function setStartTime( hour:int, min:int):void {
startHour = hour;
startMin = min;
}
public function getStartDate():Date {
var startDate:Date = new Date(fullYear, month,dayOfMonth,startHour,startMin);
return startDate;
}

public function setEndTime(hour:int, min:int):void {
endHour = hour;
endMin = min;
}
public function getEndDate():Date {
var endDate:Date = new Date(fullYear,month,dayOfMonth,endHour,endMin);
return endDate;

}
private function _getTimeDiffInMillis():Number {
var startDate:Date = getStartDate();

var endDate:Date = getEndDate();

var diff:Number = endDate.getTime() - startDate.getTime();

return diff;
}

[Transient]
public function get elapsedHours():Number {
var diff:Number = _getTimeDiffInMillis();

var hours:Number = diff / Constants.millisecondsPerHour;

var floorHours:Number = Math.floor(hours);


return floorHours;
}

[Transient]
public function get elapsedMinutes():Number {
var hours:Number = elapsedHours;
var milliHours:Number = hours * Constants.millisecondsPerHour;

var diff:Number = _getTimeDiffInMillis();

var minuteDiff:Number = diff - ( milliHours );

var minutes:Number = minuteDiff / Constants.millisecondsPerMinute;
var roundedMinutes:Number = Math.min(Math.round(minutes),59);
return roundedMinutes;

}

}
}


The only real difference is the use of Transient to tell FlexORM that these are not used in the persistence of the object.

Now that we have a feel for how to annotate our domain classes to be used by FlexORM, lets see how to persist them to the database.

I am using FlashBuilder Beta2 with FlexUnit4 RC1. I will go over the integration of FlashBuilder and FlexUnit in another blog posting. For this one I wanted to remain focused on using FlexORM.

Below is a unit test function to test Project CRUD ( create read update delete )

    [Test]
public function testCRUDNoHier():void {
trace("----------------testCRUDNoHier----------------");
var em:EntityManager = EntityManager.instance;

var p:Project = new Project();
p.name="P1";
p.desc = "proj from unit test";
p.color=0xFF001E;
em.save(p);

Assert.assertEquals("P1",p.name);

var p2:Project = new Project();
p2.name="P2";
p2.desc = "proj2 from unit test";
p2.color=0xAAAAAA;
em.save(p2);

Assert.assertEquals("P2",p2.name);
Assert.assertEquals("P1",p.name);

var p1:Project = em.loadItem(Project, p.id) as Project;
Assert.assertEquals("P1",p1.name);

var ps:ArrayCollection = em.findAll(Project);
Assert.assertEquals(2,ps.length);

p1.desc = "New P1 desc";
em.save(p1);

var p3:Project = em.loadItem(Project,p1.id) as Project;
Assert.assertEquals("New P1 desc", p3.desc);

em.remove(p2);
ps = em.findAll(Project);
Assert.assertEquals(1,ps.length);


}



We start the test method by getting a reference to the EntityManager via EntityManager.instance. The first thing we do in the test case, is to create a Project and the save it to the DB via the em.save(p).

That is all you have to do to save an entity, you do not need to write any sql yet.

To load an item for which you have the id, you use the loadItem method passing in the Project class and the id value.

To find all records for a particular class, you use the findAll method.

FlexORM even has a Criteria API. While it is not on the same level as the Hibernate Criteria, it is still very useful.

Below is an example method to find TimeEntries on a particular day:

    public static function findAllOn(fullYear:Number,month:Number=-1,dayOfMonth:Number=-1):ArrayCollection {
var teCriteria:Criteria = entityManager.createCriteria(TimeEntry);
teCriteria.addEqualsCondition("fullYear", fullYear);
if( month > -1 ) teCriteria.addEqualsCondition("month",month);
if( dayOfMonth > -1 ) teCriteria.addEqualsCondition("dayOfMonth",dayOfMonth);
teCriteria.addSort("startHour");

return entityManager.fetchCriteria(teCriteria);
}



You use the EntityManager to create the criteria for an annotated class. In this example I am using simple conditions to see that the TimeEntry has values that equal those passed in, and then sort the returned values based on the starting hour.

Again - so far I have created no sql myself. I am sure I will have a case where I need to hand craft some sql, and this will be fairly easy even with the EntityManager.

The idea behind the ORM tools, IMHO, is not to take over all of the persistence work but instead take over the mundane and tedious persistence work so we can concentrate on the more difficult tasks. So far FlexORM has done that.

I hope this quick example was useful in getting you interested in looking at FlexORM.

Next time I will discuss how I used FlashBuilder Beta2 and FlexUnit to test the application.

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Designing the Obvious

Adobe MAX2009 is coming up this weekend, and while I won't get the chance to go this year I was reviewing some of the material from years past. One presentation that I have somehow hung onto was one by Robert Hoekman Jr on 'Designing the Obvious' - from his book of the same name.

I never got the book - but I think I will now. As I was reading through the paper, he talks about something we all still come across everyday - form fields with character length limits.

He mentions some of the 'obviously' wrong ways to do this:
1) type in the field, hit submit and the system tells you that you guess wrong and that there were too many characters in the field.
2) There is a 'hint' next to the text field but it lets you type in the wrong number of characters anyways. He also noted that a 'hint' is not instructive to tell someone that spaces are or are not counted.
3) The field just lets you type in characters until it just stops. The 'stops' feedback still leaves us to wonder why the system stopped taking input.

The 'obvious' answer he suggests is to give the user real-time feedback about their input. As his book title suggests - this is so obvious.

I thought I would create a quick component that did just that - gave the user real-time feedback on their input and accounted for either including space or excluding space.

In the example application below, the first input just stops taking input at the maximum character - can you guess what that limit might be? The second input uses a StringValidator - which is a step in the right direction, but does not provide the real-time feedback.

The next two use a simple component I created. The first of those, has a 15 character limit, and spaces count toward that limit. The next one has a 30 character limit and spaces do not count toward the limit.

Getting the component to ignore spaces was trickier than I thought it would be at first - but for those curious you can download the code and see how I did this.

Source can be found by clicking here



Thanks for stopping by. I would love to hear your comments on the 'obvious'.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

Converting a Java/Flex application to Grails/Flex

I have a small reference application to CRUD ( create, read, update and delete ) notes from a back end service using a simple flex application. This reference application was originally written with Spring 2.5, later upgraded to 3, and Hibernate 3.x with MySql 5. As new versions of these technologies come out, I integrate it into this simple reference application. I use it as a sanity check while integrating all of those technologies because the application is not too difficult.

I decided to try to migrate it to a Grails platform to get a sense for how difficult that might be. I am going to share the steps that I took to migrate my Tomcat/Spring3/Hibernate3/MySql5 application to Grails/MySql5.

Since I already had a database schema from the Java implementation I decide to leverage that DDL so that both applications could run against the same backend.

Since I knew that the user interface was a Flex interface, I installed the flex plugin.

grails install-plugin flex
This plugin allows one to expose a Grails service as a Flex BlazeDS service by simply adding: static expose = ['flex-remoting'] to the service.

The 3 methods that the Java service exposed were:
* getAllNotes
* saveOrUpdateNote
* deleteNode

Therefore, to maintain the same Flex UI I needed to expose the same API.

The service ultimately ended up looking like the following:
package com.redpointtech.services
import com.redpointtech.domain.Note
class RedpointNotesService {

boolean transactional = true
static expose = ['flex-remoting']

def getAllNotes() {
def allNotes = Note.findAll()
return allNotes
}

def saveOrUpdateNote(Note note) {
def noteid = note.id
println "NOTE ID TO SAVE: " + noteid
// until I can figure out how to get unsavedValue:0 to
// work I need to do my own unsaved value.
if( noteid == 0 ) {
note.id = null;
}
note.save()
}

def deleteNote(Long noteId) {
def note = Note.findById(nodeId)
note?.delete()
}
}



Take special note of the check for a zero noteid. I could not immediately figure out how to tell grails that the 'unsaved-value' is 0 instead of the default null, so I had to make that programmatic. I am still looking into this, but if you know the answer please leave a comment.

To my pleasant surprise, the service was very small and the only extra work to expose the service to Flex was to add the 'static expose = ['flex-remoting']'. Anyone that has exposed Flex services knows that you have to add a servlet to the web.xml, update the flex-remote.xml, add a Spring factory to get the service. While not hard, certainly more work that added one line to a service. Please note, that I did NOT update the web.xml at all.

Next I turned my attention to the Note domain object. I used the the grails create-domain command to create the Note domain object.

To keep this as minimal as possible to start I did not add any constraints - clearly you would normally.

The Note domain class just keeps track of the authors name, the text of the note and the date the note was created. There is no mapping to a User domain object because I purposefully wanted to keep this reference application very simple.

Below is the Grails domain object:
package com.redpointtech.domain
class Note{

//Long id
String author
String text
Date createDate

static constraints = {
}

static mapping = {
table 'notes'
version false
id unsavedValue: 0
text column: "note_text"
createDate column: "create_date"
}

}



There are a couple of aspects to note:
* I commented out the id property because by convention Grails gives every domain object an id property.
* I had to add a mapping section because I was not able to use the grails default values.

If you look up at the service class again, you will see methods on the Note class like 'findAll' but you do not see them here. This is because GORM, which is Grails' Object Relational Mapping which sits on top of hibernate, creates many of the standard methods for you and dynamically adds them at runtime. This dramatically decreases the number of DAO methods you need to write - and really all but eliminates the DAO layer all together.

At this point, I now I have a service and a domain object that represents the Notes. Because I am using a MySql database and not the supported out of the box HSQL DB, I have a little more configuration to do.

The grails-app/conf/DataSource.groovy file contains the datasource definitions for all of the environments.

Below is the version of DataSource.groovy that I used:
dataSource {
pooled = true
driverClassName = "org.hsqldb.jdbcDriver"
username = "sa"
password = ""
}
hibernate {
cache.use_second_level_cache=true
cache.use_query_cache=true
cache.provider_class='com.opensymphony.oscache.hibernate.OSCacheProvider'
}
// environment specific settings
environments {
development {
dataSource {
pooled = false
driverClassName = "com.mysql.jdbc.Driver"
dbCreate = "update" // one of 'create', 'create-drop','update'
url = "jdbc:mysql://localhost/test"
username = "root"
password = "root"
logSql="true"
dialect = org.hibernate.dialect.MySQL5InnoDBDialect
}
hibernate {
show_sql = true
hibernate.format_sql = true
}
}
hsqldevelopment {
dataSource {
dbCreate = "create-drop" // one of 'create', 'create-drop','update'
url = "jdbc:hsqldb:mem:devDB"
}
}
test {
dataSource {
dbCreate = "update"
url = "jdbc:hsqldb:mem:testDb"
}
}
production {
dataSource {
dbCreate = "update"
url = "jdbc:hsqldb:file:prodDb;shutdown=true"
}
}
}

You can see in the environments section, I altered the development datasource to use MySql instead of HSQL. This should be pretty standard datasource configuration for MySql.

The last thing I needed to do was drop the mysql JDBC jar into the lib directory - and it was complete.

In the end I went from absolute zero, to a working Grails application that gave me the same functionality as my Tomcat/Spring/Hibernate application in less than an hour. I have to say, I was very impressed with the speed of development in the grails environment.

My company is currently working on a full featured, consumer facing Flex/Grails application and Grails has still not let me down even in this more challenging real world environment.

Every time I use Grails, I am more convinced of its viability as a production ready framework. It probably helps that it is built upon production ready frames of Spring and Hibernate.